Colony West, February 2008
Two years ago, my parents bid a joint adios to the rat race. This year, mom finally allowed dad to fulfil his long-held desire to spend three months of the Canadian winter in Florida. Turns out to have been a wise call: Toronto has been blasted with more snow this year than in any year since the Depression, mom’s joints feel lubricated and supple, and dad’s face is like that of a Cheshire cat in a grizzly bear’s body.
Personally, I love the hip-high snowdrifts, the sound of the snow crunching under your boots, and the feeling of zooming down the hill on a toboggan followed by hot chocolate and marshmallows by the fire. But try to tell that to dad, who grew up in Ottawa. Winter in Ottawa makes Toronto seem like Honolulu. In other words, he’s earned the right to spend a quarter of the year lazing by the pool, accompanying mom to lectures at the local university, and playing a little golf.
Today, he and I are playing a round together for the first time. Baseball was our shared game growing up. I didn’t embrace the links until well into my teens, and his interest in the grand old game surfaced even later. I’m in the midst of my annual West Palm Beach pilgrimage and today have abandoned my wife and our three children to play Colony West — an agreeable course in the Fort Lauderdale area, at one point ranked the fourth-hardest public course in the country — with dad, my Uncle Sid, and a few of his Florida contemporaries. Uncle Sid, despite not actually being my uncle, has always been a favorite of mine, and not just because he ran a successful ice cream company and therefore regularly stocked our basement freezer with an endless inventory of rockets, Creamsicles, fudgsicles and every other variety under the sun, summer after summer. Okay, he could’ve been a creep and I still probably would have adored him, but the fact is he’s actually a lovely human being.
Father and son — and some guy with a clipboard writing, “Prediction: Two highest scores today.”
Dad and Uncle Sid, enjoying the happiness while it lasts.
From the inside, you’d hardly know Colony West is a golf facility. It feels more like a Pittsburgh shrine. The club was founded by Pitt native Ed Rack, carried on by his son, Norman, and carried on again by Norman’s son, Craig. All three are still involved in running the club, and, to put it mildly, still moderately proud of their heritage at the town at the confluence of the Allengheny and the Monongahela. Framed photos of Lynn Swann to Mario Lemieux and everyone in between line virtually every inch of the inner walls, from the pro shop to the bar to the front edge of the bathroom. Take a random Pittsburgh teenage boy’s bedroom walls and expand it twentyfold, and you’ve got the inner walls of Colony West.
Colony West: Golf course on the outside, Pittsburgh shrine on the inside
Today is notable also for the fact that I’ll be using hybrids for the first time. I’m borrowing Uncle Sid’s son Alan’s clubs, a set of Aliens (not to be confused with alien wedges; Alien is a make). Even during my warmup swings they feel glorious.
A quick inspection of the course from the front of the clubhouse reveals what seems like a typical Florida track: flat, semi-inspired, lots of water and, especially, sand, to make up for lack of undulation. But I’m not going to be fooled — I happen to know that, when the Championship Course was originally designed for the Jackie Gleason Classic (which became the Honda Classic), the Golden Bear said the course was too tough for the event, and the tournament committee agreed. I also happen to know Jack took a seven on the then-third hole, now twelve.
The course’s vegetation appears somewhat sparse — a result of having been ravaged by Hurricane Wilma of 2005, like so many other courses in the region. To reach the first hole, in fact, one must guide the cart along a roped-off path of gravel and wood chips where work is still being done. Another glance upward and I see that two-thirds of the trees lining the first part of the fairway are cut off at the stumps.
As we approach the first, a short par four, Harry Kaplan (Cappy) jokes to Harry Shapiro (Shappy) that he’s going to drive the green. The starter, who looks like Moses in khakis and a golf shirt, says, “What are you smoking?” This is me and my friends four decades from now.
Ron Ganetsky (Rube), leading off, smacks a drive 150 yards down the middle of the fairway. The others have all agreed to play from the whites, and since I don’t want to disrespect my elders, I don’t argue. Dad, like a walrus holding a toothpick, steps to the tee and pokes his ball 100 feet directly upward. Then he hits his mulligan off the toe and straight out of bounds. I’m fascinated to observe that he’s rushing his hands on every swing, the very evil I try so desperately to avoid. What a revelation: My golf defects are hereditary.
After a decent drive, I pull out the 3-hybrid and hit a nice sizzler that turns left. Then I catch a 5-iron that feels tremendous off the clubface, which makes it little surprise that the ball finds the one outlying branch hanging from the one tree of any kind in my way, and kicks straight back down. This is the first of several such branches minding their own business that my balls will find today. From 50 yards, I hit an accidentally beautiful wedge — if only I knew what I did on that swing so I could do it again at some point — to within a few feet, allowing me to save a six.
Here I am drilling an iron off the tee. Note the way I’m falling over on my right instep. Textbook.
At the 350-yard second, one must hit over a river that continues up the left side of the fairway, a dogleg left. I tee off with the 3-hybrid, swing off my back foot and hit a thin one that fades too far and splashes into the edge of river. The day’s first bit of rage flares inside me, then subsides.
My composure (I know to enjoy it while it lasts) enables me to then hit a monster 3-wood that bends around the dogleg. But my pleasure is quickly doused by my discovery of the main problem playing with older men: No one can ever see where anyone else’s ball landed.
The third is a mirror-image of the second: severe dogleg right and a lake running up one side of the fairway that remains harmless if one can just manage to keep the ball somewhere within an imaginary 50-yard corridor off the tee. With my 4-hybrid, I hit it thin but straight, then, facing another 170 yards to the green — a fairly clear shot over a couple of minor swales — thunk a 5-iron into the first of them. Then, from 80 yards, I manage another beautiful wedge that kicks off a mound and rolls to within six feet of the hole.
With guarded enthusiasm I privately speculate whether the One Club Law is at work on my wedge today. It’s a phenomenon every amateur golfer knows well: No matter how dismal your game, in every round one club in your bag will prove cooperative from the first to the eighteenth. The problem with this law is twofold: first, it’s rarely the same club from one round to the next, and second, it’s impossible to predict which club will step up, so one usually has to undergo the pains of trial and error for a few holes before finding out.
For example, if I had to lay money, I’d never in a hundred rounds bet on my wedge. But in three holes I’ve now hit two good shots with it, compared with two good shots for all my other clubs combined. I don’t want to get too excited, because the flipside of the rule is to make a premature determination about a certain club based on a few early shots only to find out after several disastrous ones that it is not, in fact, the club being smiled upon, and that the one holding the magic that day has sat in your bag for thirteen holes.
At the fourth, an easy-looking 300-yard dogleg right with another lake lining the fairway — this time running along its left edge — I select my 4-hybrid and rip my drive off a tree and into a backyard of one of the condos abutting this section of the course. A rail-thin kid throws it back to me with a snicker. Selecting my 7-iron instead, I let my front arm go slack at impact, causing the clubface to open and the ball to roll far left. I’m an expert at lengthening holes this way.
Now facing a 240-yard shot that must skirt the lake, I keep my head down and my arms stiff, laying good metal on a 3-hybrid. Anticipating a nice soft landing on, or at least near, the green, I begin to smile … until I see the splash. Ah, the hidden tongue of lake cutting into the fairway too far ahead to see — just one of the many course nuances that can victimize the weekend golfer. And it isn’t even the weekend.
In addition to dad’s rushing his hands forward, he, again like me, has an abridged backswing. I can only attribute this, again, to genes, since we’ve never played together, meaning neither one of our backswings could be responsible for the incompleteness of the other’s. His is somehow even shorter than mine, and I thought there wasn’t a golfer on the planet whose backswing was shorter than mine. Because of dad’s overall size, he has a hard time getting his body out of the way of his swing in the first place, leading to more hazardous consequences as a result of the truncated backswing. I just hope one of us, during our lifetimes, finds the lost parts.
Dad swinging at an imaginary ball. I think that’s it behind him.
At the fifth, a 140-yard par three, I hit a respectable 6-iron into the breeze, but it lands right of the green. Then I pull the chip, too, which strains to make it over a ridge and onto the green but runs out of gas and instead rolls right off it. Attempting again to chip on, I let my wrists go slack. The ball creeps up to the edge of the green and stops, mocking me with complete and utter justification. I two-putt to salvage a contemptible 5.
Over the next few holes I mentally force myself to move on from constant private lamentations about how deficient my golf game is to more or less unadulterated enjoyment of being out on the links with dad — who, to his credit, is clearly bottling his own frustration for my sake. Cappy, who introduced himself to me twice at the beginning of the day due to failing eyesight, hits a wild one off the tee at the par-3 eighth, prompting Uncle Sid to say, “You know how many directions that went in?” Uncle Sid, who has the long, slow backswing followed by hellacious forward swing like a wind-up toy gone haywire characteristic of many recreational golfers, follows Cappy, unleashing a wild one himself that would surely have made Cappy grin if he’d seen it.
Cappy, 75-percent sure he hit the ball
Returning to my 5-iron just in case it’s today’s mystery club, I skid one left off the tee. It bounces softly off the base of a maple. Hitting a provisional, I stick with the 5-iron but let the face open and pop it up to the right. The ball hits a different tree and caroms back toward me. I choose to play the first ball, switch to my 7-iron — maybe it’s the one — and hit another pop-up, which rolls into a trap fronting the green. These are the kinds of shot sequences that cause me to tap aimlessly at the ground with my club while saying “Wow” — as in, “Wow, I can’t believe how much I want to jump in that lake and drown.”
At the ninth, a 349-yard par-4, I overcompensate for slice by aligning my feet too far to the right and nail yet another tree — amazingly, my fifth of the day —right in the heart of the trunk. My ball kicks back and to the right. Now sitting off the fairway and peering through a thick row of trees, I mash a 3-wood, miss the first row, and find a tree in the hidden second row. The ball kicks back again, even further than the first shot. Sometimes I forget how poor I am at golf; moments like these remind me. I’m almost behind the original tees now. I throw a mini-tantrum, muttering a few words to the effect of, “Aw, gee whiz,” and Dad says, “Cool it, cool it.” I feel like I’m in peewee baseball again trying not to throw my bat into the other team’s dugout after striking out.
Dad taking a minute after a poor shot so his son doesn’t see him go insane
After nine, my scorecard shows mostly 6’s and 7’s. My only two good shots were the two wedge approaches. Colony West is playing more like Penal Colony West.
Rube falls asleep in mid-swing
On the tenth, yet another good wedge sets me up for a 7-foot par putt. Uncle Sid tells me, “When in doubt, Florida putts are straight.” But I’m sure I see a slight break, so I aim an inch right of the cup – and that’s exactly where the ball goes, passing the hole by two feet. Uncle Sid doesn’t say a thing.
Throughout the back nine Uncle Sid completely unravels, spraying his ball with astonishing waywardness, just as Dad begins to gain a microcosmic measure of consistency.
Rube hitting, Uncle Sid providing close watch. Maybe he should have parked the cart right on top of his ball instead.
Uncle Sid loves the term “leaking,” especially to describe various shots of mine. (“That ended up pretty straight, but you’re still leaking a bit.” “That one leaked.” “Faded back into the fairway, even though it leaked a bit.”) Each one of these comments is accurate, which ticks me off.
Uncle Sid’s unorthodox putting style. Another word for it is “ridiculous.”
On the par-5 fourteenth, having run off a string of particularly ugly sevens to start the back nine, I poke a sweet drive down the left side of the fairway, then a decent 3-wood to a bunker 80 yards shy of the green. Then I hit that one into another bunker 30 yards left of the green. From that one, I sail the green, then get back on and two-putt. Another seven. I think I’ll change my name to Seven Schecter.
The charming par-4 sixteenth, which will end up a lot less charming after I find the trees twice, followed by water.
Over the last several holes I manage plenty of shots that would make golf instructors wince, featuring three-putts, back-foot finishes and slackened wrists leading to what Uncle Sid would describe as repeated leaking. I finish with a 106, squarely in my usual pitiful range. But it’s been a goo day. I was playing golf, after all.
My shadow trying to separate itself from me. It pulls this trick every time I play golf.
Big slice coming. Note how my weight is completely forward already. Textbook again.
The egret to whom I offered $20 to help look for my ball on seventeen. He declined.
STARTING AND FINISHING HOLES
Colony West kicks off and winds down unremarkably but pleasantly enough. Eighteen is a nice dogleg right that skips over some water toward the hole.
OVERALL AESTHETICS
The hurricane dealt Colony West a significant blow, but ownership has worked hard to restore it. This is a lovely course that resembles a person who wouldn’t turn heads but whom you’d never describe as unattractive, either. It wins extra points for egret and salamander.
REAR VIEWS
I judge courses not just from the way holes look tee to green but also how they look from the green back to the tee. If a hole can still impress me after I’ve just three-putted for seven, it deserves accolades. Colony West achieved this several times, and not just because I carded so many sevens. It’s a course in harmony with the land surrounding it.
TRACK
Colony West offers just enough variety to keep things interesting. A few doglegs left, a few right, some water, and a sufficient amount of pleasant scenery. The playing conditions are so good, Colony West is appointed host of the Florida Greenskeepers Annual Golf Tournament.
“NICE HOLE” FACTOR
While none of Colony West’s holes will take your breath away, few will make you comment in the other direction, either. The signature hole is twelve, a par-4 guarded by trees and water on the left, trees and out of bounds on the right, and the completely unfair requirements of both an accurate drive to get into position and a second accurate shot in a row to reach the green, itself protected by a bunker on the left and water on the right. That is one annoying hole.
DEGREE OF DIFFICULTY
Colony West doesn’t tip its hand as a tricky course, but it is — the Florida State Golf Association rated it the longest and toughest par 71 in the state with good reason. The trickery is subtle. I only realized it the sixth time I hit a tree, for instance. The course has five sets of tees, allowing golfers like me to play poorly from a variety of distances.
COURSE MARSHALS
Barely a presence. My kind of course.
PRO SHOP AND AMENITIES
The vibe at Colony West is more beach party than golf course. There’s always an enjoyably raucous crowd at Sand Trap, the open restaurant outside the clubhouse, a buzz inside, and ample smiles to go around.
BANG FOR YOUR BUCK
Colony West is a great buy at any time. With greens fees ranging from as high as $50 to as low as $15 after 5:30 pm (you have to love Florida), you’ll never feel you didn’t get your money’s worth.
